What are the symptoms of a bad shift solenoid

What are the symptoms of a bad shift solenoid

IPGGutenbergUKLtd/iStock/Getty Images

Your transmission shift solenoids mount on the transmission valve body that controls fluid flow through the various circuits and passages in the transmission. The solenoid plungers are constantly bathed in fluid from the transmission, and metal salt from the manufacturing process and normal wear, as well as detritus from the friction materials can collect on the plungers and cause them to bind in their bores and fail to function properly. Identify these failures by the symptoms they produce.

Driving Symptoms

Your transmission relies upon the positions of multiple solenoids to control the gear selection. If one or more solenoids are bad, you may lose the use of one or more gears, and may even be stuck in one particular gear or unable to shift into any gear at all. Do not confuse a slipping transmission with a solenoid problem. You will hear and feel the difference when you try to shift. A slipping transmission will actually shift, but then not produce any power once in gear, whereas a bad solenoid will prevent the shift from occurring in the first place.

Associated Systems

Most modern vehicles have some sort of transmission control module that monitors the transmission through various sensors, such as the shift-position sensor and the transmission speed sensor. Additionally, the TCM and solenoid wiring are protected by fuses. Any failure in the fuses, sensors or associated wiring can result in conditions that prevent the solenoids from working properly.

Limp-In Mode

The TCM will detect failures within the systems that it monitors and any failure, from a bad solenoid to a blown fuse, will trigger a limp-in mode designed to prevent further damage to the transmission while allowing some limited capacity to travel. Typically, the limp-in mode will place the transmission into second gear and keep it there. This leads to a sluggish feeling when initially accelerating from a standing stop, and high engine revolutions when traveling faster than around 30 mph. This is meant to be used to return home or to a service center if a failure occurs. Do not continue to use the vehicle before rectifying the problem that triggered the limp-in mode.

Diagnostic Trouble Codes

Once the TCM detects a problem in the monitored systems, it sets a diagnostic trouble code that can be retrieved using a scan tool appropriate for the year and make of the vehicle in question. The trouble codes for transmission control components begin at P0700, and the codes specific to the solenoids range from P0751 through P0758. Additionally, there are speed sensor codes that run from P0500 through at least P0503. Check the DTCs against the model-specific codes set forth by the manufacturer.

Writer Bio

TJ Hinton trained as an auto mechanic at Mississippi Gulf Coast Community College and then later graduated from MMI as a certified motorcycle mechanic . He's also worked for 20+ years in home construction, remodeling and repair. His articles appear on InternetAutoGuide.com and TopSpeed.com.

What are the symptoms of a bad shift solenoid

Deep within your vehicle’s underpinning is a complex set of machinery that allows your car to shift between gears. Your automobile’s transmission system — a combination of gears, sensors, hydraulics, and fluid — helps your vehicle accelerate and decelerate with ease, enabling a smooth ride. 

One of the lesser known elements of a transmission system is the solenoid. These small valves regulate the transmission system’s operation, allowing transmission fluid to move freely when triggered by the engine and other sensors. If you begin to notice transmission issues with your vehicle, one place to look is at the solenoid.

What Is a Transmission Solenoid?

Your vehicle’s transmission is operated by small valves known as solenoids. These electro-hydraulic valves control the flow of the transmission fluid within the transmission system by opening and closing when they receive electrical signals. These signals may come from the engine, other sensors, or the transmission control unit, which notifies the transmission to kick in as the engine speed rises or falls.

In automatic transmission systems, solenoids are vital to ensuring that the automation of gear shifting occurs quickly and fully. Of the transmission solenoids, there are three main types: the transmission shift solenoid, the lockup solenoid, and the transmission control solenoid.

As the engine or transmission control unit signals the solenoids, the valves will open or close to regulate the movement of transmission fluid. Should that process begin to slow down or fail, the pressurization of the transmission clutch and bands will cause the shifting of gears to slow, slip, or possibly fail. Knowing the signs of potential solenoid problems can help ensure the proper repair of these essential pieces of equipment before it’s too late. 

Signs and Symptoms of Failing Transmission Solenoids

Wondering how to know if your transmission solenoids may be failing? Here are the top symptoms that your solenoids aren’t functioning properly:

  • You experience delayed gear shifting and a sense of pulling or slipping when trying to shift between gears.
  • The vehicle will not downshift as you slow down. An inability for the solenoid valve to operate may prevent your car from downshifting, and the engine will continue to rev as you attempt to brake.
  • You may discover that the transmission will not shift out of neutral, as the solenoid is not receiving the proper signals or opening enough to shift the transmission.
  • The gear shifts may seem rough or erratic, leading to a shaky or rocky feeling in the vehicle when you attempt to shift gears, accelerate, or decelerate.
  • Your vehicle’s Check Engine Light (CEL) may come on, indicating that the electrical system has noticed a failure in a system. 

Understanding “Limp Mode”

Solenoid issues may cause your vehicle to go into “limp mode,” a mode created to shield your engine and transmission from catastrophic failure and a severe accident. In Limp Mode, the entire vehicle will begin to grow weak in its power and the ability to accelerate. This will often come with difficulty to shift or control the speed at which your vehicle is traveling. 

It is essential that you pull over and stop the vehicle in a safe location when this mode is triggered. Your vehicle’s inability to shift into gear will keep you from achieving higher driving speeds — so avoid highway driving. Continuing to operate your vehicle while in “Limp Mode” can cause serious damage to your engine and transmission.

What To Do If You Fear You Have A Solenoid Problem

When it comes to solenoids, these unique and complex pieces of machinery may be a bit too complex for the average driver to fix on their own. If you suspect your vehicle’s transmission solenoids are acting up, the first step should be to visit a trained and experienced transmission technician.

The best way to ensure that you head off any potential solenoid problems is to always take your vehicle in for recommended routine maintenance. As part of your vehicle’s maintenance, a trained mechanic will take a look at the transmission and analyze the solenoid’s health. This will help them to determine if you are in need of a solenoid repair or replacement. 

Seek Expert Help With Transmission Issues

One reason drivers fear transmission issues or failure is that the cost to fix or replace a transmission is usually high. When your transmission begins to show signs of problems, seek the help of a trained professional immediately who can identify and address issues.

With transmission solenoids often being an unknown part of your transmission system, knowing the symptoms of problem or failure can help you handle problems fast and ensure that your vehicle stays healthy and on the road for years to come. 

Tags: Transmission Solenoid Issues

What happens when a shift solenoid fails?

You experience delayed gear shifting and a sense of pulling or slipping when trying to shift between gears. The vehicle will not downshift as you slow down. An inability for the solenoid valve to operate may prevent your car from downshifting, and the engine will continue to rev as you attempt to brake.

Can you drive with a bad shift solenoid?

Yes, you can drive a vehicle with a bad transmission solenoid. Nevertheless, you should keep in mind that the problem may escalate into an expensive repair if not taken care of as soon as possible.

Can I replace transmission solenoid myself?

Replacing a transmission shift solenoid can be done by most any auto repair shop, automobile dealership service center or you can do-it-yourself “DIY”.